Updated: March 2026 data
Cicero, NY

The Cottages At Garden Grove, A Skilled Nrsg Comm

5460 Meltzer Court, Cicero, New York 13039
(315) 699-1619
156 Certified Beds
Medicare and Medicaid
Non-profit Corporation
2★
Overall
2★
Health Insp.
4★
Staffing
2★
QM
56.8
Score /100
#428
in New York
#9,880
of 14,676 nationally
National Rank
#428
of 596 in New York
State Rank
#1
of 1 in Cicero
City Rank
$511
NY median · semi-private
Daily Cost

Inspection caution: health inspection rating is 2 stars. Review the official CMS profile before making a decision.
56.8
score
Composite Quality Score / 100
State rank #428 · National rank #9,880 · How rankings are calculated

Visual Snapshot
Occupancy
138 residents for 156 certified beds · 88% occupied

CMS Ratings
Overall, inspection, staffing, and quality measure ratings on the CMS 1–5 scale.

Facility Details
156
Certified Beds
138
Avg Residents/Day
4h 15m
Weekday Nurse Hrs
88%
Estimated Occupancy
Accepts MedicareAccepts MedicaidNon-profit Corporation

CMS Ratings Breakdown
Metric This Facility New York Comparison
Overall Rating 2 / 5 3.0 / 5 1.0 below NY avg
Health Inspection 2 / 5 2.8 / 5 0.8 below NY avg
QM Rating 2 / 5 3.9 / 5 1.9 below NY avg
Long-Stay QM 1 / 5 4.0 / 5 3.0 below NY avg
Short-Stay QM 3 / 5 3.6 / 5 0.6 below NY avg
Staffing Rating 4 / 5 2.7 / 5 1.3 above NY avg

This table compares the facility to New York averages for the six CMS rating categories.

Staffing, Weekend Coverage & Turnover
4h 15m
Weekday Total Nurse
3h 57m
Weekend Total Nurse
38m
Weekday RN
21m
Weekend RN
Metric This Facility New York Difference
Total nurse hours / resident / day 4h 15m 3h 39m +36m
RN hours / resident / day 38m 42m −4m
Licensed hours / resident / day 1h 15m 1h 28m −13m
Physical therapist hours / resident / day 9 min 7 min +2m
Weekend total nurse hours 3h 57m 3h 10m +47m
Weekend RN hours 21m 28m −7m
Total nursing staff turnover 40.8% 40.5% +0.3 pts
RN turnover 48.1% 40.5% +7.6 pts

Lower turnover is better. Tiny therapy-hour values are shown in minutes so they are easier to understand.

Cost of Care in New York
$511
Per Day
Semi-private
$15,528
Per Month
State median
$186,333
Per Year
State median
62% above
Vs National
CareScout/Genworth

State median private-pay cost for a semi-private room. Actual facility pricing can differ.

Data Disclaimer & Methodology

Data Disclaimer: All data on this page is sourced from the official CMS (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) Nursing Home Compare dataset for March 2026. This includes facility ratings, staffing hours, inspection scores, fines, complaints, and geographic coordinates when available. NursingHomesNearMe.org does not independently verify, collect, or alter this facility data.

Composite scores and rankings are calculated by NursingHomesNearMe.org using a published methodology that combines CMS ratings, staffing inputs, and enforcement flags into a normalized 0–100 score. Information may not reflect current facility conditions. Always contact the facility directly and verify at medicare.gov/care-compare before making care decisions.

Data: CMS Nursing Home CompareProcessing Date: 2026-03-01Rankings across 14,676 U.S. facilities

Want more context before deciding?

Use the official CMS profile, compare the nearby homes, and ask each facility how recent inspection issues were resolved.

All data from CMS Nursing Home Compare (2022–2026). Composite scores calculated by NursingHomesNearMe.org. Not endorsed by CMS. Always verify at medicare.gov/care-compare before making any care decision.